background image

Your Mid-Level Donors Deserve More

Your Most Loyal Donors are Being Ignored. Let’s Fix That.

The Donors You’re Overlooking Could Be Your Biggest Opportunity

Your mid-level donors are already fueling your mission—giving 3–10x more than entry-level supporters. They’re loyal, passionate, and just one intentional moment away from becoming major givers. 


But most aren’t getting the experience they deserve. They’re stuck in CRM silos. Treated like $50 donors. And churning just when they’re ready to lean in. 


We know your team is under-resourced and overwhelmed. That’s why we built the Mid-Level Accelerator—a scalable donor engagement solution that meets your team where you are.

What Success Looks Like

Your peers are already seeing major results

$500k

raised from four families who had never given more than $2,500

115

new major gifts prospects identified

34%

increase in post-call average gift

71%

retention of stewarded mid-level donors

Scalable Tiers for Any Team

Take Your Mid-Level Program to the Next Level

Take Your Mid-Level Program to the Next Level

Mid-Level Accelerator

 

Already have a mid-level program and team in place—but ready for a smarter, more targeted approach? 

 

AGP’s Mid-Level Accelerator is designed to elevate your strategy with: 

  • A Custom Annual Strategic Roadmap
    Tailored engagement plans and a proven omnichannel approach to drive deeper donor connections. 
  • Smart Donor Targeting
    Empower your team with the right donors, the right message, at exactly the right time. 
  • Stronger Donor Relationships
    Increase retention and loyalty by creating more meaningful and personalized donor experiences. 
  • Proactive Major Gift Identification
    Uncover your next major gift prospects—before they raise their hand. 

Enterprise-Level Support for High-Volume Programs

Enterprise-Level Support for High-Volume Programs

Mid-Level Concierge Solution

 

Designed for organizations with a large and growing mid-level donor base, AGP’s Concierge Solution offers fully managed, end-to-end execution—so your team can focus on what matters most. 

 

  • Turnkey Mid-Level Program Management
    AGP handles every aspect of your mid-level donor experience with precision and care. 
  • Multi-Channel Personal Stewardship
    Build lasting connections through personalized outreach—phone, email, handwritten letters, and more. 
  • Your Dedicated Donor Engagement Specialist
    A fully embedded team member who acts as an extension of your brand and mission. 
  • Consistent Major Gift Pipeline Growth
    Surface your next major gift opportunities—delivered directly to your relationship managers for faster, bigger results. 

The Cost of Waiting

Every day you wait, potential walks out the door. Your mid-level donors are giving more than most—and they’re ready for more. But without intentional engagement, they stall out, disengage, or quietly churn.

Waiting doesn’t buy time. It costs you:

  • Upgrade-ready donors who slip away without ever raising their hand
  • Team energy spent chasing short-term goals instead of building lasting value
  • Major gift momentum that never gets off the ground

But you don’t need a massive lift to start moving:

  • Retention is your smartest growth strategy—it’s faster and more cost-effective than acquisition
  • Our tools and team help you scale without extra headcount
  • With the right message at the right time, your next major donor is already in your file

Explore More Mid-Level Resources

Article

What Is Really Holding Nonprofits Back From AI?

Webinar

Mid-Level Fundraising: Effectively Stewarding = Increased Generosity for Future Stability

Article

Sustainer Giving: How to Drive Engagement From Donors

form background

Your Mid-Level Moment Is Now

 

Let’s build the donor experience your supporters already deserve—before year-end.

Complete the form to get in touch and learn more.