background image

Donor Prioritization & Upgrade

Upgrade donors with purpose and precision

Upgrades don’t happen by accident. We help you identify donors who are ready to increase their engagement, map intentional advancement pathways, and create experiences that strengthen commitment — so value grows with purpose, not pressure.

Design donor growth with intention

Upgrades don’t happen through bigger asks—they happen when you truly understand your donors. We help you uncover real capacity and affinity, identify who’s ready to deepen their support, and build clear pathways that encourage natural progression. Along the way, we shape experiences that strengthen trust and long‑term relationships. Research shows that donors who report being very satisfied with their experience are twice as likely to give again, yet few organizations measure or manage that satisfaction. As Trent Ricker, AGP’s CEO, reminds us, “If you’re not building loyalty, you’ll be caught in a dangerous cycle.” Our approach turns that cycle into sustainable donor growth.

Advance donors across every channel

Upgrades succeed when every channel works together—not in silos. We build coordinated journeys across direct mail, email, digital, phone, and personal outreach, ensuring donors experience rising relevance as their commitment deepens. Multichannel connections strengthen trust, a key driver of repeat giving.

Find the donors ready for more

GivingDNA reveals who has the capacity, affinity, and intent to support at greater levels—long before gift size shows it. By blending behavioral signals with wealth and demographic insights, organizations can identify true upgrade potential and move donors with precision, not guesswork. Data‑driven targeting consistently accelerates major‑gift pipelines.

Grow mid-level & major donor value

Donor upgrade programs thrive when sustainers and mid‑level donors feel seen, and when planned giving and major‑gift prospects feel inspired. We design stewardship and engagement that elevate trust, deepen satisfaction, and expand commitment—qualities proven to double the likelihood of continued giving and long‑term donor growth.

What We Offer

Services and technology designed for donor prioritization & upgrade

Analytics
AGP turns your campaign and website data into decisions you can act on. We set up and audit tracking across GA4, Piano, and other platforms, build dashboards that surface what actually matters, and connect the dots between traffic, engagement, and conversion. The result is a clear picture of what’s working, what isn’t, and where to focus next.
Audience Insights
AGP transforms donor and audience data into insights that drive smarter fundraising decisions. Using advanced analytics, GivingDNA, and industry expertise, we uncover who your supporters are, what motivates them, and where the greatest opportunities for growth exist. By turning complex data into clear, actionable recommendations, we help organizations refine strategy, strengthen donor engagement, and make more confident investments across acquisition, retention, and stewardship efforts.
GivingDNA
AGP helps nonprofits transform data into smarter fundraising decisions with GivingDNA, our donor intelligence and analytics platform. By unifying donor, giving, wealth, engagement, and behavioral data, GivingDNA reveals who donors are, what motivates them, and where the greatest opportunities exist. Organizations gain the insights needed to improve segmentation, prioritize outreach, strengthen fundraising performance, and create more meaningful donor relationships.
Multichannel Fundraising
AGP transforms individual fundraising tactics into connected donor experiences. Our team integrates direct mail, email, digital advertising, web, social media, and donor data to create coordinated campaigns that reach supporters with the right message at the right time. By breaking down channel silos and measuring performance holistically, we help organizations deepen engagement, improve efficiency, and drive stronger fundraising results.
Sustainer and Mid-Level Donor Programs
AGP brings strategy, data, and donor-centered stewardship together to grow sustainer and mid-level giving programs. We help organizations identify high-potential supporters, deliver personalized experiences, and build meaningful relationships that inspire greater commitment over time. By increasing retention, recurring revenue, and donor lifetime value, nonprofits can create a stronger foundation for long-term fundraising success and future major donor growth.

We Help You Identify Upgrade‑Ready Donors and Design Purposeful Journeys.

Start transforming donor potential into sustained revenue.

The right insights change everything. AGP equips fundraisers to recognize upgrade readiness and create journeys that deepen commitment and long‑term value

Ryan carpenter
VP, Donor Engagement, AGP 

Experts

Our Strategists

Alyssa Boger

EVP, Client Experience

Sarah Hartke

SVP, Client Growth & Strategic Markets

Ashleigh Lambert

VP, Client Strategy

Liz Lowe

VP, Client Relationships

Ryan Carpenter

VP, Client Success

Stephanie Drahan

VP, Account Management

David Sacchetti

AVP, Client Strategy

Jessica Woodard

AVP, Client Strategy

Kathy Giles

AVP, Client Strategy

Kim Richardson

AVP, Client Strategy

Megan Garner

AVP, Client Strategy

Lisa Cassell

Digital Art Director

Colleen Patel

Senior Customer Success Manager

Related

Article

Become Your Own Donor: Would You Give Again?

Article

What Food Bank Donors Are Telling Us: Motivation Is High. Friction Is the Problem

Webinar

Mid‑Level Isn’t a Stepping Stone: Here’s How NAMI Turned It into a Growth Engine

form background

Stay ahead with ideas that move nonprofits forward

Get the latest AGP guides, webinars, articles, and podcasts in your inbox, curated to sharpen your strategy and keep your mission moving forward

form background

Ready to talk strategy?