Over the course of this series, I’ve looked at the pressures shaping food bank fundraising and what donors are telling us about how they want to engage. 

Now comes the practical question: What do we do with all this information? 

As food banks plan for 2027, I believe the goal has to be bigger than raising more money. We need to build fundraising programs that give organizations more revenue they can count on. 

That requires looking beyond the success of the next appeal or campaign and asking whether the overall fundraising program is becoming more stable. 

Build for Stability, Not the Next Surge 

Food banks will always need to respond quickly when hunger makes headlines or an urgent community need emerges. But sustained community need requires a fundraising structure designed for more than just those moments. 

For me, fundraising stability means being able to provide for your community without having to rely on crisis fundraising. 

That starts internally. Fundraising programs need the structure to welcome new donors, steward them well and build a continuing relationship after the moment that first brought them in.  

It also changes how we think about growth. 

A big response to one direct mail campaign can be a win. A spike in digital giving can be a win. But neither tells you on its own whether your donor program is becoming healthier. For 2027, food banks should be looking more closely at how those individual wins contribute to reliable revenue over time. 

Protect the Donors You’ve Already Earned 

If budgets and staff capacity are tight, stewardship and donor education should remain priorities. Those are often among the first areas to feel pressure when resources are constrained. Yet they are essential to helping donors understand why their support continues to matter after their initial gift. Food insecurity is a 365-day issue, and donors need opportunities to understand the ongoing role they can play in addressing it.  

That makes donor retention and reactivation especially important. 

Our donor sentiment research found that 66% of surveyed lapsed donors said they were likely to give to a food bank again in the next 12 months. Twenty-five percent said they hadn’t given because they hadn’t been asked recently. 

Those findings should make every food bank take a fresh look at its existing donor file. 

Before continually investing to replace donors who leave, pay attention to why donors are lapsing and whether you’re giving them meaningful reasons to stay connected. Then make sure you are inviting lapsed supporters back. 

Create More Durable Layers of Support 

Two areas I would look at closely are mid-level giving and monthly giving. 

Mid-level donors have already demonstrated a meaningful commitment to your organization. The opportunity is to deepen those relationships with a donor experience that reflects that commitment. That can also create a stronger bridge between broad-based fundraising and major giving. 

Monthly giving provides another layer of stability by giving donors a straightforward way to support the mission throughout the year. AGP’s Giving Outlook: Food Bank Edition found that most of our food bank partners saw strong year-over-year growth: donor counts rose 15–25% on average, new donors grew 125–150% and revenue increased 25–30%. 

For a food bank looking to develop these programs, start at a scale your team can manage. A small mid-level portfolio assigned to one person can be a starting point. A branded program may make sense if it resonates with your donors and community. Donor surveys can also help you understand what supporters want from the relationship, because those preferences will vary from community to community.  

The goal is to build the relationship over time. Food insecurity isn’t going away, so we need fundraising programs prepared to support an ongoing mission.  

Measure What Matters Across the Whole Program 

One of the most important changes food bank fundraising teams can make in 2027 is to measure success through an omni-channel lens. 

Direct mail remains important. Digital fundraising matters. Email has a role. But donors experience all of those touchpoints as communication from one food bank. 

That means your measurement should help you understand the donor relationship across channels. Look at net revenue and donor behavior indicators alongside individual campaign results so you can see whether you are keeping more of the donors you earn and building stronger programs over time.  

The same thinking should guide your communications. 

A direct mail appeal and an email don’t have to look identical. Different channels have different requirements. But the donor should recognize the same organization, mission and voice across them. Inconsistent experiences can introduce doubt, which is why development, marketing and communications teams need to work together rather than operating in separate channel silos.  

This integrated approach is also consistent with the broader fundraising environment: AGP’s Giving Outlook identifies omni-channel programs as essential, with direct mail and paid media providing complementary lift alongside digital monthly giving programs. 

Stay the Course and Bring Your Community with You 

The challenges facing food banks are real. Fundraising teams are responding to sustained need while donor participation and expectations continue to shift. 

There is also a tremendous amount of strength already within this sector. 

The charitable food system has been doing this work for more than 60 years. Food bankers have made it through difficult periods before. What matters now is keeping the mission at the center and making sure everyone is working toward the same goal.  

That alignment extends across the organization. Donors experience your direct mail, email, digital advertising, stewardship, website and community presence as one relationship with your food bank. Every interaction shapes their understanding of your organization and their place in the mission.  

There is good reason to keep believing in that relationship. Donors still care deeply about hunger in their communities. AGP’s food bank donor research found that 83% of respondents were likely to give to a food bank in the next 12 months, while 46% said they give because they want to ensure no one in their community goes hungry. 

So, stay the course. Keep the mission top of mind and bring your community with you.

There will rarely be a perfect strategy for a difficult moment. Do the best you can with what you have, continue believing in the mission and remember the strength that already exists in the food bank community. 

We’ve made it through hard times before. We can do this. We will do this. And we’ll do it by bringing our communities with us.  

To catch up on the first two articles within this series, read part 1: The State of Food Bank Fundraising: The Gap Between Rising Need and How Giving Is Evolving; and part 2: What Food Bank Donors Are Telling Us: Motivation Is High. Friction Is the Problem.